It is believed that Andy is still unmarried as there is no any information about his married life, spouse and divorce in the media. But there is some rumor about his love affair in the media. It is said that he has been dating Alaina Zieman since 2011. Alaina Zieman is a fashion model.
Andy was enrolled at Menomonee Falls High School and he earned his high school graduation from there. His first musical instrument was saxophone but while he was in his high school, he played percussion in bands. After his high school graduation, he joined University of Wisconsin–Milwaukee with a major in anthropology and history. He has been active as a musician since 1996. During his early days, he played in the bands like Racetraitor, Killtheslavemaster, Project Rocket, xFor Death or Gloryx and so on. During the late 1990s, he worked on Vegan Reich's EP Jihad as its guest drummer. In 2003, he joined an American rock band Fall Out Boy. Soon after he joined this band, he worked on their debut album and their debut album Take This to Your Grave was finally released on 6th of May 2003. After releasing four albums, Fall Out Boy went on a musical hiatus and then he formed a heavy metal supergroup The Damned Things with guitarist Joe Trohman. They debut album Ironiclast was released on 14th of December 2010 and this band went on a hiatus after that. Fall Out Boy resumed its musical journey from the early 2013 and their fifth album Save Rock and Roll was released on 12th of April 2013. The actual figure about his annual salary is unknown but his net worth is said to be around $14 million dollars.