In 2008, Sammi was seen with Mike 'The Situation' Sorrentino as a loving couple. Their romantic love life was well known in the public media that time. However, these love affairs came to an end in 2009.
At the end of 2009, Sammi was seen with Ronnie Ortiz-Magro holding his hands. Ronnie is also a famous television personality. They dated each other for about half a decade and they finally broke up in 2014.
While Sammi was enrolled at Raritan High School, she won soccer letter. After her high school graduation, she joined William Paterson University. There she majored in Sociology. She also played as a midfielder on the university's women soccer team. She has been active in television since 2009. That year, she appeared in the MTV's hit reality show Jersey Shore. She has also appeared in the DVD movie, The Three Stooges playing the role of Sammi.